How AAOIFI Standards Are Changing the Sukuk Landscape

Sukuk, or alternatively called Islamic bonds, are one of the fastest-growing segments of the global financial market. They offer a way for investors to earn returns while complying with the principles of sharia, or Islamic law. But not all sukuk are created equal. Depending on the issuer, the structure, and the jurisdiction, some sukuk may be more Shariah-compliant than others.

This is where the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions (AAOIFI) comes in. AAOIFI is an international body that sets standards and guidelines for Islamic finance, including Sukuk.

In this blog post, we will explore how AAOIFI standards affect the sukuk market, and what it means for issuers and investors based on the recent publication by the fitch ratings. We will also look at some of the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead for this dynamic sector.

Read my other posts here: Conventional Finance - FinFormed, Islamic Finance - FinFormed, Takaful - FinFormed, Career - FinFormed and Randow Writings - FinFormed

What are AAOIFI standards and why do they matter?

AAOIFI standards are a set of rules and recommendations that cover various aspects of Islamic finance, such as accounting, auditing, governance, ethics, and Shariah.

AAOIFI standards are not mandatory, but they are widely adopted and respected by the industry.

One of the main areas that AAOIFI standards cover is Sukuk. Sukuk are certificates that represent proportional ownership in an underlying asset or project. They differ from conventional bonds in that they do not involve interest payments, which are prohibited in Islam. Instead, Sukuk investors receive a share of the profits or revenues generated by the asset or project.

However, not all sukuk are structured in the same way. There are different types of sukuk, such as Murabaha, Ijarah, Wakalah, Musharaka, and Mudaraba, that reflect different modes of financing and risk-sharing. Some sukuk are more asset-backed, meaning that the investors have a direct claim on the underlying asset. Others are more asset-based, meaning that the investors only have a contractual right to the cash flows.

AAOIFI standards aim to ensure that sukuk are aligned with the spirit and objectives of sharia. They specify the criteria and conditions for issuing, trading, and redeeming sukuk. They also address some of the controversial issues and practices that have emerged in the sukuk market, such as:

• The use of purchase undertakings, which are agreements that allow the issuer to buy back the Sukuk at a predetermined price at maturity or in case of default. AAOIFI standards require that the purchase price should reflect the market value of the underlying asset, not the face value of the sukuk, to avoid any element of interest or debt.
• The maintenance of a minimum tangibility ratio, which is the proportion of tangible assets to total assets in the Sukuk structure. AAOIFI standards require that the tangibility ratio should be at least 33%, to ensure that the sukuk are not based on mere financial claims or debts, but on real economic activities and assets.

How are AAOIFI standards impacting the sukuk market?

AAOIFI standards have a significant impact on the sukuk market, as they influence the behavior and preferences of issuers and investors. Some of the effects of AAOIFI standards are:

• They increase the demand and liquidity for AAOIFI-compliant sukuk, especially from Islamic banks and funds that follow AAOIFI standards or local regulations that are based on them. For example, UAE Islamic banks, which are key Sukuk investors, issuers, and arrangers, have to comply with AAOIFI Shariah standards due to local regulations. They may not be able to invest in sukuk that are not AAOIFI-compliant, or may face restrictions on reselling them in the secondary market. This creates a premium for AAOIFI-compliant sukuk, and a discount for non-compliant ones.
• They encourage the adaptation and innovation of sukuk structures and documentation, to meet the requirements and expectations of AAOIFI standards. For example, most sukuk issued in 2022 and 2023 have clauses in the documents that link the purchase undertakings, the tangibility ratios, and the compliance with AAOIFI standards. These clauses are added by issuers to accommodate UAE Islamic banks, and to enhance the credibility and attractiveness of their sukuk. Some issuers also use hybrid or novel structures, such as wakala-murabaha, to achieve AAOIFI compliance and diversify their funding sources.
• They create challenges and opportunities for sukuk issuers and arrangers, depending on their size, frequency, and jurisdiction. For large or frequent sukuk issuers, such as sovereigns and banks, AAOIFI compliance may not be a major obstacle, as they have the resources and expertise to navigate the complexities and costs involved. They may also benefit from the wider investor base and lower pricing that AAOIFI compliance offers. For smaller or less frequent issuers, however, AAOIFI compliance may be more difficult and expensive, as they may face limited access to AAOIFI-compliant assets, higher legal and advisory fees, and longer issuance time. They may also have to compete with larger issuers for the same pool of investors.

What are the prospects and challenges for AAOIFI standards and the Sukuk market?

AAOIFI standards and the Sukuk market are both evolving and growing, as they respond to the changing needs and preferences of the Islamic finance industry and its stakeholders. Some of the prospects and challenges that lie ahead are:

• The harmonization and standardization of sukuk across different markets and jurisdictions, which would enhance the efficiency, transparency, and comparability of sukuk, and reduce the legal and regulatory uncertainties and risks. However, this may also face barriers due to the differences in Shariah interpretation, implementation, and supervision across markets and institutions^Sukuk. AAOIFI plays a key role in facilitating the dialogue and cooperation among the various stakeholders, and promoting the adoption and convergence of its standards.
• The development and diversification of Sukuk^Sukuk products and services, which would cater to the different needs and preferences of issuers and investors, and support the growth and stability of the Islamic finance industry. For example, there is a potential for more green and social sukuk, which would align with the environmental, social, and governance (ESG) principles and objectives of Shariah.
• The education and awareness of Sukuk among the general public and the financial community, would increase the understanding and appreciation of Sukuk, and foster trust and confidence in the Islamic finance industry. For example, there is a need for more information and research on the features and benefits of Sukuk, and how they compare and contrast with conventional bonds. There is also a need for more training and capacity building on the standards and best practices of Sukuk, and how to apply and implement them. AAOIFI contributes to the education and awareness of sukuk, by publishing and disseminating its standards and guidelines, and by organizing and participating in various events and programs.

Conclusion

Sukuk are an integral and important part of the Islamic finance industry, and AAOIFI standards are a vital and valuable tool for the sukuk market. They provide the criteria and conditions for issuing, trading, and redeeming sukuk, and ensure that they are aligned with the principles and objectives of sharia. They also affect the demand and supply, the structure and documentation, and the pricing and performance of sukuk, and create challenges and opportunities for issuers and investors.

AAOIFI standards and sukuk market are both dynamic and evolving, as they adapt to the changing needs and preferences of the industry and its stakeholders. They also face prospects and challenges, as they seek to harmonize and standardize, to develop and diversify, and to educate and inform. AAOIFI plays a key role in shaping and supporting the sukuk market, and enhancing its efficiency, transparency, and credibility.

Here are the main points of this blog post:

• AAOIFI standards are a set of rules and recommendations that cover various aspects of Islamic finance, including sukuk.
• AAOIFI standards aim to ensure that sukuk are aligned with the spirit and objectives of sharia, and specify the criteria and conditions for issuing, trading, and redeeming sukuk.
• AAOIFI standards have a significant impact on the sukuk market, as they influence the behavior and preferences of issuers and investors, and encourage the adaptation and innovation of sukuk structures and documentation.
• AAOIFI standards and sukuk market are both evolving and growing, as they respond to the changing needs and preferences of the industry and its stakeholders, and face prospects and challenges for the future.
• AAOIFI plays a key role in facilitating the dialogue and cooperation among the various stakeholders, and promoting the adoption and convergence of its standards.

P.S. We would love to hear your thoughts on this topic. Do you think AAOIFI standards will continue to shape the future of the sukuk market? Share your thoughts in the comments below! Your insights could help others understand this complex yet fascinating subject better.

Remember, no insight is too small, and every perspective matters! 🌟

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this blog are not necessarily those of the blog writer and his affiliations and are for informational purposes only.

Subscribe on LinkedIn

Follow us on social media @Linkedin